Yes. You can create a free Excel comparison template by listing your options in columns, recording the same criteria for each, and—if some criteria matter more—using weighted scores to compare them. The layout below works in Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows; you can also build it in Excel for the web, though some menus and template options differ.
What a comparison template should include
A useful comparison sheet puts alternatives side by side and makes the basis for a decision visible. It can compare products, supplier quotes, software plans, job offers, travel options, or project proposals. The right fields depend on the decision: a laptop comparison might include price, memory, weight, warranty, and battery life, while a vendor comparison might focus on total cost, delivery time, support, and contract terms.
At minimum, include an option name, the criteria you are comparing, and a place to record the evidence or rating for each option. Add a notes column for details that do not fit neatly into a number, such as exclusions in a quote or a product feature that is useful only to one person. If criteria have unequal importance, include weights and calculate a weighted total. Keep source links or quote dates nearby when information can change.
A comparison spreadsheet does not make a subjective choice objective. It makes assumptions easier to inspect. A score of 4 for customer support is meaningful only if you have defined what a 4 means and applied that definition consistently.
Build a basic comparison sheet in Excel
For a small comparison, make one row per criterion and one column per option. In Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows, open a blank workbook and enter the labels directly. One workable layout is:
- Row 1: a title, such as “Supplier comparison.”
- Row 3: option names and any headline facts, such as the quoted price.
- Row 5: column headings for Criterion, Weight, Option A rating, Option A weighted score, Option B rating, and Option B weighted score.
- Rows 6–10: the criteria, such as price, quality, features, support, and delivery.
- Row 11: a total for each option, followed by notes or a recommendation area if needed.
For example, enter Option A’s price in B3 and Option B’s price in C3, with labels in A3 and the result label in D3. In the comparison table, use columns A through F as described above. This layout keeps the raw rating separate from its weighted score, so a reader can see how the result was produced.
To make the sheet easier to scan, select the headings and choose Home > Bold, then use Home > Format as Table if you want a formatted, filterable table. Freeze the heading area with View > Freeze Panes if the comparison is long. On Excel for Mac, the same features are available, but ribbon placement and some menu labels can vary slightly. Excel for the web has a similar ribbon, though its template gallery and certain formatting controls may differ.
Add weights and formulas without hiding the logic
Weights express how important each criterion is. If the five criteria are price, quality, features, support, and delivery, you might assign weights of 30%, 25%, 20%, 15%, and 10%. These add to 100%. Give each option a rating on a consistent scale, such as 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent). For criteria such as price, decide in advance whether a higher rating means cheaper or better value; otherwise, the scale can be confusing.
With the weight in B6 and Option A’s rating in C6, enter this in D6, then fill it down through D10. It multiplies the rating by that criterion’s weight. For a 30% weight and a rating of 4, the result is 1.2.
=B6*C6
With the weight in B6 and Option B’s rating in E6, enter this in F6 and fill it down through F10. For the same 30% weight and a rating of 5, the result is 1.5.
=B6*E6
With Option A’s weighted scores in D6:D10, enter this in D11 to add them. If the weights are 30%, 25%, 20%, 15%, and 10%, and its ratings are 4, 5, 4, 3, and 4, the total is 4.10 out of 5.
=SUM(D6:D10)
With Option B’s weighted scores in F6:F10, enter this in F11. If its ratings are 5, 3, 5, 4, and 3, the total is 4.15 out of 5. Under these illustrative assumptions, Option B edges ahead by 0.05 points; that small gap is a reason to inspect the underlying ratings, not to treat the result as a decisive verdict. These formulas use ordinary Excel arithmetic and SUM, so they work in current desktop Excel and Excel for the web.
If you also want to show how the prices differ, with Option A’s positive price in B3 and Option B’s price in C3, enter this in D3. For prices of $120 and $108, respectively, the result is -10%, meaning Option B costs 10% less than Option A. Format D3 as a percentage. This calculation assumes B3 is not zero and compares B’s price with A’s as the baseline.
=(C3-B3)/B3
Choose criteria and scoring rules carefully
Start with the decision the sheet is meant to support, then choose criteria that distinguish the options. Avoid adding a criterion merely because it is easy to measure. For a software subscription, a low monthly price may not capture required user limits, setup charges, renewal terms, or whether essential features are included. For a purchase, compare the same model or service level and use prices from a similar date.
Write down what each rating means before scoring. A simple scale might define 1 as “does not meet the requirement,” 3 as “meets the requirement,” and 5 as “exceeds it.” Use 2 and 4 for cases in between. If a criterion is a measured quantity, record the actual value as well as any rating. For example, show delivery as “8 days” in a notes or evidence field, then rate it against an agreed delivery target.
- Keep criteria distinct. “Build quality” and “durability” may overlap unless you define them separately.
- Set weights before looking at which option wins, where practical, to reduce the temptation to adjust them to favor a preferred result.
- Use the same rating scale for every option and note when evidence is missing.
- Include non-negotiable requirements separately. A high total should not compensate for failing a required safety, compatibility, or contract condition.
Make the result readable and checkable
Give the workbook a clear title and identify the date or version of the information. Use consistent units, such as monthly prices rather than a mixture of monthly and annual amounts. If one option’s price includes tax or delivery and another’s does not, flag that difference instead of comparing the raw figures as if they were equivalent.
Use formatting to guide attention rather than to replace explanation. Bold headings, sensible column widths, and a restrained fill color can make the sheet clearer. Conditional formatting can highlight a high or low value, but state what the color means; red should not automatically imply “bad” if the underlying measure is something like performance. For an Excel table, select the range and choose Home > Format as Table. For a color rule, select the relevant cells and choose Home > Conditional Formatting.
Before relying on a total, check that all weights add to 100%, every rating is within the chosen scale, and no formula was overwritten by a typed value. Test one row manually: a 20% weight times a rating of 3 should produce 0.6. Confirm that the final total is the sum of the weighted rows and that an option with a missing rating has not been treated as if it received a fair score. A visible note such as “not rated” is more informative than an unexplained blank.
Common problems and limitations
The most common problem is false precision. A total of 4.15 versus 4.10 may look scientific, but the ratings and weights are judgments, and the difference may be smaller than the uncertainty in the evidence. Consider whether a reasonable change to one weight or rating would change the ranking. If it would, describe the choice as close and identify the deciding trade-off.
Another issue is mixing qualitative and quantitative facts without a clear rule. A price is a measured amount; “easy to use” is a judgment. Keep the original facts visible and explain how a rating was assigned. Also avoid double-counting: if “monthly price” and “overall affordability” measure essentially the same thing, including both may give cost more influence than the weight column suggests.
Finally, a weighted score is not always the best decision method. If one option fails a must-have requirement, a high score elsewhere should not erase that failure. Record mandatory criteria as pass/fail or use a separate eligibility check before comparing the remaining choices.
Where to find a free template and what to check
Excel may show ready-made workbooks in its template gallery. In Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows, choose File > New and search the available templates for terms such as comparison or decision matrix. Availability depends on the installed version, account, and connected template catalog, so a particular comparison template may not appear for everyone. Excel for Mac also has a template gallery under File > New, with a slightly different interface.
You can also start from a blank workbook and use the layout above; that is often the simplest free option because you control the criteria and do not have to remove irrelevant fields. Excel for the web can be used with a Microsoft account, although its features and access conditions can change and some workbook functions differ from desktop Excel. If you download a workbook from another site, check that it contains no unexpected macros, external links, or hidden sheets before entering sensitive information. A basic comparison sheet should not need macros.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a free comparison template in Excel?
Excel’s File > New gallery may offer relevant templates, but what appears can vary. A blank workbook is a free alternative: enter options, criteria, ratings, and formulas using the layout described above.
How do I compare two products in Excel?
Put the products in separate columns and the same attributes in rows. Record comparable facts, such as price and dimensions, and use a consistent rating scale for subjective criteria. Add notes for trade-offs that a number cannot capture.
How do I make a weighted comparison in Excel?
Assign each criterion a weight, make the weights total 100%, rate every option on the same scale, multiply each rating by its weight, and sum those weighted scores. Check that the scale direction is consistent.
Can I use this comparison template in Excel for the web?
Yes. The basic cells, multiplication formulas, and SUM formula work in Excel for the web. Some template-gallery choices and interface details differ from Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows.
Should I choose the option with the highest score?
Not automatically. Check the assumptions, evidence, and size of the score gap, and consider mandatory requirements that a total cannot represent. A close result may call for a qualitative judgment rather than a claim that one option is clearly better.
Related
- Excel SUM with Multiple Criteria: How to Do It
- Excel: Subtract the Same Value From Multiple Cells
- Excel Spreadsheet Keyboard Shortcuts: A Practical Guide
Try it: the Date Difference Calculator: days, months, years and weekdays between two dates, with the DATEDIF formulas.
More in How-to basics
- How to Create Inbox Rules in New Outlook Step by StepTo create an inbox rule in New Outlook, open Settings > Mail > Rules, select Add new rule,…
- Google Sheets Add Item to Dropdown: Steps and TipsTo add an item to a Google Sheets dropdown, select a cell that uses the dropdown, open Data…
- Excel Heat Map Over a Map: Methods, Data, and SetupYes. In Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows, use 3D Maps to place a heat map over a…
- Excel Text Upside Down: What Works and What Doesn’tIn Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows, you cannot rotate text inside a worksheet cell a full 180…
- Google Sheets Conditional Formatting: Using BordersNo. Google Sheets’ built-in conditional formatting cannot add or change cell borders when a rule is met; its…
- Combine Cells in Excel on a New Line with CHAR(10)To combine values from A2 and B2 in one cell with a line break between them, enter =A2&CHAR(10)&B2…
Sources: Function behaviour and menu paths: Microsoft Support documentation for Excel. Method & sources
Spotted an error in this guide? Let us know.