Free Comparison Chart Template for Excel: How to Build One

Charts & pivot tables · Updated November 20, 2026

Yes. You can make a free comparison chart template in Microsoft Excel by listing the options in rows, the criteria in columns, and—if a single ranking is useful—adding scores or weights. The layout below works in Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows; build it in a blank workbook, then save a clean copy to reuse.

What a comparison chart template does

A comparison chart puts several alternatives beside one another so you can evaluate the same attributes consistently. It can help compare products, software plans, service providers, job candidates, project proposals, or possible locations. A good template makes the criteria visible and keeps unlike information from being mistaken for a direct numerical comparison.

There are two common formats. A feature matrix records facts or descriptions, such as whether a plan includes support or what a product costs. A scored comparison assigns ratings to criteria and may calculate a total. The matrix is usually best when readers need to inspect the evidence; a score is useful when you need a concise shortlist. You can include both in one workbook.

Excel does not have one universal comparison-chart template that fits every decision. A reusable workbook should therefore make it easy to change the options, criteria, notes, and scoring rules without hiding how the conclusion was reached.

Choose a format that fits the decision

Start by deciding what the chart needs to communicate. If the options have a few clear, factual differences, use a feature matrix. If you are comparing many criteria that matter by different amounts, add a weighted score. Avoid giving everything a numerical rating just because Excel can calculate one: a score can make subjective judgments look more precise than they are.

  • Feature matrix: Best for side-by-side facts, such as price, warranty length, compatibility, or included features.
  • Simple scorecard: Best when the criteria are reasonably comparable and have similar importance.
  • Weighted scorecard: Best when some criteria matter more, such as reliability over appearance.
  • Pros-and-cons comparison: Best when important trade-offs are difficult to reduce to a number.

For example, a laptop comparison might list price, weight, battery-life claims, memory, warranty, and notes. Those details should remain visible even if you calculate a score, because one total cannot explain every trade-off.

Build a reusable comparison chart in Excel

Open a blank workbook in Excel for Microsoft 365 on Windows. A practical starting layout uses one row for headings, one row for each option, and one column for each criterion. Put the option name in the first column and keep notes beside the relevant facts rather than in a separate document.

  1. Enter clear headings. In row 1, use labels such as Option, Cost, Quality, Ease of use, and Notes. Replace these examples with criteria relevant to your decision.
  2. Add one option per row. Enter the same types of information for every alternative. If a fact is unavailable, write Not provided or leave it blank consistently; do not treat missing information as a zero score.
  3. Make the range a table. Select the data and choose Insert > Table. Confirm that the table has headers. Tables make it easier to filter and sort the comparison, and they expand as you add rows.
  4. Format for scanning. Use concise headings, sensible number formats, and wrapped text for long notes. Keep units explicit: distinguish dollars per month from a one-time price, for example.
  5. Freeze the headings for long lists. Choose View > Freeze Panes > Freeze Top Row so the column labels remain visible while you scroll.
  6. Save a reusable blank. Keep a version with example entries or scores cleared, then use Save As to create a new workbook for each decision. This protects the original layout.

For a simple product comparison, a blank structure might look like this:

Option Price Warranty Feature A Feature B Notes
Option 1
Option 2
Option 3

This is a comparison table rather than a graph, and that is often the clearest starting point. You can add a chart after deciding which values are genuinely comparable and useful to visualize.

Use a consistent scoring scale

If you want to rank options, define the scale before assigning ratings. A 1-to-5 scale is easy to understand, but the meaning of each number should be written down. For example, for ease of use, 1 could mean difficult for the intended user and 5 could mean easy with little training. For cost, decide whether a high score means lower cost; otherwise the direction of the score may be confusing.

Use the same scale for all options and score each criterion independently. Add a Notes column to record why a rating was given, particularly when ratings involve judgment. If several people are scoring, agree on the definitions first or ask everyone to score separately before discussing differences.

To reduce accidental entries, select the cells intended for ratings and choose Data > Data Validation. Set Allow to Whole number, then set the minimum to 1 and maximum to 5. This limits entries to the chosen range, though it cannot ensure that a rating is fair or supported by evidence.

Add weights when criteria matter unequally

Weights express the relative importance of criteria. For example, a team might give reliability more weight than appearance when comparing equipment. Keep the weights visible in the sheet, and ensure they use one consistent scale. Percentage weights are convenient when they add to 100%, but the formula below also divides by the total weight, so it can work when the entered weights do not sum to 100%.

Suppose the headings are in A1:E1: Option, Cost, Reliability, Ease of use, and Weighted score. Put the weights 40%, 35%, and 25% in B1:D1, and enter each option’s ratings in B2:D2. With the first option rated 4 for cost, 5 for reliability, and 3 for ease of use, enter this in E2: =SUMPRODUCT(B2:D2,$B$1:$D$1)/SUM($B$1:$D$1). The result is 4.1 on a 1-to-5 scale: (4 × 0.40) + (5 × 0.35) + (3 × 0.25) = 4.1. Copy the formula down for other options, keeping the weight references fixed.

This calculation assumes higher ratings are better for every criterion. If a lower value is better, such as dollars spent or delivery time, define a suitable rating scale first rather than mixing raw costs with 1-to-5 ratings. Do not compare totals if the alternatives have different missing criteria or if some ratings use a different interpretation.

Make the comparison easy to read

Use formatting to draw attention to information, not to imply certainty. For a rating range, select the rating cells and choose Home > Conditional Formatting > Color Scales. A color scale can help readers spot high and low values, but include the numbers too; color alone may be hard to interpret, particularly in print or for readers with color-vision differences.

If the weighted scores are the main result, a column chart can show how the options compare. Select the option names and score values, then choose Insert > Insert Column or Bar Chart > Clustered Column. Give the chart a descriptive title and check that the category labels match the correct scores. A chart of totals is not a substitute for the underlying criteria: keep the comparison table in the workbook so readers can see what drove the result.

For detailed text-heavy comparisons, a chart may make the sheet more crowded rather than clearer. Use filters on the Excel table to focus on particular options, or group criteria into sections such as Cost, Performance, and Support. Avoid merged cells within the data range because they can make sorting and filtering difficult.

Check assumptions and common problems

Comparison sheets are only as useful as their inputs. Before relying on a ranking, check that prices use the same period, measurements use the same units, and claims come from comparable sources. A monthly subscription should not be compared directly with a one-time purchase without making the time basis clear. Similarly, a warranty length alone may not describe what the warranty covers.

  • Missing data: Mark it clearly and investigate whether the gap affects the decision. A blank should not silently become a low rating.
  • Criteria overlap: Avoid counting the same quality twice, such as scoring both speed and performance when your definitions substantially overlap.
  • False precision: A total like 4.13 does not mean the judgment is accurate to two decimal places. Consider showing one decimal place or the underlying ratings.
  • Changing information: Record the date checked and, where practical, a source or link for facts that can change, such as prices or plan features.
  • One-size-fits-all weights: A score reflects the weights you chose. Someone with different priorities may reasonably rank the options differently.

A useful check is to see whether a small change in one weight reverses the ranking. If it does, explain that the decision is sensitive to priorities rather than presenting the top score as an unquestionable winner.

Free ways to get or reuse a template

The steps above require no paid add-in: you can create the layout in Excel and save it as a normal workbook. Excel’s File > New screen may also show online templates, depending on the templates available to your installation and connection. Search there for terms such as comparison or decision matrix, then review the workbook structure before entering important information. Template availability and design can vary.

You can also adapt a simple workbook shared by an organization or create the table in another spreadsheet application, but check that formulas, formatting, and charts transfer as expected if you later open it in Excel. If your needs are only a few columns of facts, a formatted Excel table may be simpler than downloading a specialized file. Avoid opening unexpected attachments or enabling macros in a template unless you trust its source and understand why the macro is needed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Excel have a free comparison chart template? Excel may show downloadable templates under File > New, but the choices can vary. You can also make the table in a blank workbook using the layout above and save it for reuse without buying a separate template.

How do I compare two products in Excel? Put each product in its own row and use columns for the same facts, such as price, size, warranty, and features. Use consistent units, include notes or sources, and add scores only if a defined scale helps answer your question.

How do I make a comparison chart in Excel with scores? Enter consistent ratings for each option, define what each rating means, and calculate a total or weighted average if needed. For a visual comparison, select the option names and resulting scores and insert a clustered column chart.

Can I use a weighted comparison chart for non-numeric criteria? You can assign ratings to qualitative criteria, but state the rating definitions and keep notes about the evidence. A weighted total summarizes those judgments; it does not turn subjective assessments into objective facts.

Should I use a table or a graph? Use a table when readers need detailed facts, notes, or trade-offs. Use a graph when a small set of comparable numbers needs a quick visual comparison. Many useful workbooks include a table as the evidence and a chart as a summary.

Related

Try it: the Percentage Formula Generator: percent of, percent change, increase and decrease, with the formula.

More in Charts & pivot tables

Sources: Function behaviour and menu paths: Microsoft Support documentation for Excel. Method & sources

Spotted an error in this guide? Let us know.